| Presidents of The Cathedral Club of Brooklyn | |
| Lewis E. A. Drummon | 1900-1901-1902 |
| Claude M. Becker | 1903 |
| John J. Kuhn | 1904-1905 |
| Edward J. Connolly | 1906-1907 |
| David T. Leahy | 1908-1909 |
| Eugene F. O’Connor, Jr. | 1910-1911 |
| Frank J. Bruning | 1912 |
| John J. Curtin | 1913-1914 |
| Frank C. Russell | 1915 |
| Thomas H. Cross | 1916 |
| James F. McEvoy | 1917 |
| John F. Casey | 1918 |
| George J. O’Keefe | 1919-1920 |
| Leo J. Hickey | 1921 |
| James J. Golden | 1922-1923 |
| Frank R. Decker | 1924 |
| William D. Breen | 1925 |
| Harry T. Woods | 1926-1927 |
| Edward V. O’Brien | 1928-1929 |
| Vincent H. Carr | 1930 |
| Joseph P. Reilly | 1931 |
| Thomas S. Murnane | 1932 |
| J. Raymond McMahon | 1933 |
| Albert S. McGrover | 1934 |
| Bernard M. Halloran | 1935 |
| Arthur G. Grampp | 1936 |
| Edmond M. Hanrahan | 1937 |
| John P. McGrath | 1938 |
| John D. Shea | 1939 |
| Michael F. Clavin | 1940 |
| Raymond J. McGrover | 1941 |
| James J. McCourt, Jr. | 1942 |
| George C. McCullough | 1943 |
| William H. Midwinter | 1944 |
| Thomas G. Grace | 1945 |
| James W. Smith | 1946 |
| William Ziegler, Jr. | 1947 |
| Daniel J. Brannigan | 1948 |
| Francis A. McGrath | 1949 |
| John J. Coakley | 1950 |
| Edwin V. Smith | 1951 |
| Quinton C. Van Wynen | 1952 |
| Constantine J. Hilbert | 1953 |
| Albert C. Boye | 1954 |
| William J. Cahill | 1955 |
| Raymond J. McGowan | 1956 |
| George W. Hunt | 1957 |
| Joseph T. McNulty | 1958 |
| Richard G. Hickey | 1959 |
| Joseph M. Rhatigan | 1960 |
| John G. Breslin | 1961 |
| Francis E. Sullivan | 1962 |
| Frank Ziegler | 1963 |
| Albert J. Byrnes | 1964 |
| Howard F. Fenn | 1965 |
| John E. Larney | 1966 |
| Peter E. Dwyer | 1967 |
| Robert H. Peters | 1968 |
| John J. Woods, III | 1969 |
| Joseph T. Egan | 1970 |
| Michael F. DeVito | 1971 |
| J. Lincoln Hallowell | 1972 |
| Robert J. E. Murphy | 1973 |
| Thomas J. Power | 1974 |
| John A. Carrese | 1975 |
| James P. Wickham | 1976-1977 |
| David P. Roche III | 1978 |
| Roger G. Canal | 1979-1980 |
| Robert Charles Golden | 1981-1982 |
| John Joseph Gilhooly | 1983-1984 |
| Steven J. Dorn | 1985 |
| J. Peter Clavin | 1986 |
| John Flood Serena | 1987 |
| Kevin A. Murray | 1988 |
| Robert J. Geary | 1989 |
| Kevin A. Reilly | 1990 |
| Charles S. Gucciardo | 1991 |
| Kevin M. Kearney | 1992 |
| Charles A. Collins | 1993 |
| Eleanor I. Breslin | 1994 |
| Sharon E. Miggins | 1995 |
| Bettyann McDonough | 1996 |
| Michael J. Carr | 1997 |
| Jerry V. Sullivan | 1998 |
| Thomas A. McCarthy | 1999 |
| Francis J. DeLustro | 2000 |
| Vincent M. Del Giudice | 2001 |
| Richard A. Re | 2002 |
| Craig A. Eaton | 2003 |
| Joseph B. Guarinello | 2004 |
| Joseph A. Bova | 2005 |
| James F. Kelly | 2006 |
| Frank J. Keating | 2007 |
| George R. Prezioso | 2008 |
| James B. McHugh | 2009 |
| Robert W. Johnson | 2010 |
| Michael Perrette | 2011 |
| John L. Heyer II | 2012 |
| Martin J. Cottingham | 2013 |
| Christopher P. Hannan | 2014 |
| Vincent D. LeVien | 2015 |
| Mark Cipolla | 2016 |
| Antonio Biondi | 2017 |
| Brian Long | 2018-2019 |
| Pat Russo | 2020-2022 |